You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.
Republicans have been redrawing congressional districts this year at President Trump’s behest, but so far it hasn’t seemed to be enough to deny Democrats a reasonable path to control of the House of Representatives.
That might change if the Supreme Court strikes down Section 2 of the 1965 Voting Rights Act in Louisiana v. Callais, a case the court hears Wednesday.
Without Section 2, which has been interpreted to require the creation of majority-minority districts, Republicans could eliminate upward of a dozen Democratic-held districts across the South.
Republicans may not eliminate every Democratic-leaning district that they technically could (more on why later), but the party’s aggressive mid-cycle redistricting suggests they would eliminate enough to obtain a significant structural advantage. It’s not clear whether this would occur by next year’s midterm elections, with a court ruling likely next summer, but the new seats would eventually be enough to make Republicans favored to win the House even if they lost the popular vote by a wide margin.
With those new seats added to the ones Republicans already seem poised to gain, the House would not be competitive in most election years.
How can Democrats win the House if
states redraw districts?
Democrats would probably need to win the national
popular vote by these percentage-point margins if …
Texas, Missouri and Utah
are the only states to redistrict
+1.3 Dem. margin needed
California redistricts
+0.2 Dem.
Florida, Indiana, Ohio
and Kansas redistrict
Florida, Indiana, Ohio
and Kansas redistrict
+1.4 Dem.
+2.4 Dem.
Section 2 is struck
down and Southern
states redistrict
Section 2 is struck
down and Southern
states redistrict
How can Democrats win the House if states
redraw districts?
Democrats would probably need to win the national popular vote
by these percentage-point margins if …
Texas, Missouri and Utah
are the only states to redistrict
+1.3 Dem. margin needed
California redistricts
+0.2 Dem.
Florida, Indiana, Ohio
and Kansas redistrict
Florida, Indiana, Ohio
and Kansas redistrict
+1.4 Dem.
+2.4 Dem.
Section 2 is struck down and
Southern states redistrict
Section 2 is struck down and
Southern states redistrict
+4.4 to +5.6 Dem.
+5.1 to +6.1 Dem.